Ashes
greats rip into England
London,
August 6: England's
cricketers found themselves under fire again on Monday from a host
of former players in press reports following their latest Ashes
capitulation.
After
going down to a seven wicket thrashing by Australia inside three
days at Trent Bridge - a match that gave the visitors an unbeatable
3-0 lead in the series - there proved to be no hiding place for the
vanquished.
Inquests
into the state of English cricket following defeat at the hands of
the old enemy are nothing new: this was Australia's seventh
successive Ashes series victory and they are on course to equal the
achievement of their 1920-21 predecessors in beating England 5-0.
However,
England's current players may be entitled to wonder how, with this
welter of insight, the country ever lost a Test while the 'old boys'
were out in the middle.
Former
England opening batsman Geoff Boycott said, with usual modesty, that
what the team needed most was a batsman capable of grafting all day
- in short, a player much like himself.
``Our
batting is getting worse, not better,'' he said in the Daily
Telegraph. ``No matter how excellent our bowling is, we don't bat
well enough to make Australia take a second new ball, and without
runs we are never in a position to win.
``So
many people talk about batsmen being able to play shots. Our problem
is that we cannot stay in. The first thing I look for in a good
batsman is his ability to defend.
``I
ask myself has he got a good defensive technique. It's not because I
want batsmen to be blockers but because if you can't stay in, you
can't make runs.''
And
Boycott added: ``What England would not give for a (Ken) Barrington
or Boycott who would bat all day.''
He
also said that all-rounder Craig White and Ian Ward should be
dropped, with Mark Ramprakash given a final warning at best although
Boycott said now was not the time to bring in a replacement for
veteran wicket-keeper Alec Stewart.
Boycott's
former England team-mate Ian Botham, not for the first time,
disagreed with 'Sir Geoffrey' and said Essex wicket-keeper/batsman
James Foster should be brought in.
``I
believe England should start building for the 2002/3 Ashes in
Australia now. That means including a young wicketkeeper-batsman in
their squad for the fourth Test at Headingley next week,'' Botham
told the Daily Mirror.
``Jamie
Foster is one youngster who should be brought into the squad and
England must also consider Vikram Solanki, Usman Afzaal, Owais Shah
and Durham's Nicky Peng,'' added the all-rounder who almost
singlehandedly secured the Ashes for England on home soil 20 years
ago.
Botham's
friend, colleague and fellow former England captain David Gower
slammed Ramprakash for the way in which he gave his wicket away
against Shane Warne in the second innings but warned that now was
not the time for wholesale changes.
``Nobody
but Ramps can imagine what was going through his mind when he
decided to play that shot at such a crucial time,'' he said in the
Sun.
But
Gower added that new recruits for Headingley, where the fourth Test
starts on August 16, could be in for a torrid time.
``Potential
replacements like Usman Afzaal, Owais Shah and Jamie Foster would be
facing a cock-a-hoop Australian attack on potentially the most
bowler-friendly wicket at Leeds - a mind-blowing experience,'' he
said.
Another
former captain, Bob Willis, said the county system must shoulder
much of the blame for England's poor performances.
``For
10 years now I have been warning that full-time professional cricket
in this country is not capable of producing the type of player able
to withstand the heat,'' the fast bowler told the Daily Mail.
He
added: ``Australia and South Africa have a pyramid of excellence
that leads players from school cricket through a tough league system
and then into the first-class game. Only when they are on the brink
of the national side do they have to decide whether to become a
full-time professional.''
Meanwhile,
former Australia captain Allan Border also had his say.
``All
the good work done by Nasser Hussain and Duncan Fletcher over the
past 18 months has sadly been wiped out,'' he wrote in the Mirror.
But
he did add: ``It is obvious that while you Poms are capable of
beating any other side in the world, there is a massive mental
problem when facing Australia. The players have scars that they
can't overcome.''
Still
it's worth remembering that as long ago as 1882 England were being
written off.
A
seven run defeat by Australia at The Oval led to a mock obituary of
English cricket in the 'Sporting Times'. It concluded: ``The body
will be cremated and the ashes taken to Australia.''
That's
how the Ashes got their name: whether any of the current 'death
notices' has such a lasting impact remains to be seen.
|